Sign-up for the Sprint/Speed Clinic here!

Run coaching, Family coaching

Two Sports, One Season:   the good, the bad and the ugly.  

Cross country + soccer is the most common in-season double for Pennsylvania high schoolers. It’s tempting: more playing time, more fitness, more fun. But does the endurance engine of cross country really pair with the speed-and-sprint metabolism of soccer—and at what cost?  Because this is a very sensitive topic, I included many sources in this article. We also look at soccer and football, volleyball  and cross country/soccer

At first glance, the benefits seem obvious—better fitness, more opportunities, more fun. But the risks are real too: overuse injuries, burnout, and divided focus. So, is playing two sports in the same season a good idea? 

Few families have lived this question as closely as the Fishers. Grant Fisher, now the American record-holder in the 5000m and 10,000m, was once a Michigan high schooler recruited for both NCAA Division 1 soccer and cross country. We talked to his mother, Sonia Fisher, about balancing a two sport, one season schedule for a high achieving athlete in high school.  

Quick notes on youth specialization and volume

Major sports medicine bodies caution against early, high-volume specialization because it’s linked to overuse injuries and burnout. The NFHS Sports Medicine Advisory Committee recommends variety, off-days, and multi-sport participation across a year, not necessarily simultaneously in the same season. Their position flags risk when weekly hours and months-per-year in one sport creep too high. NFHS

 A 2019 AMSSM summit summary pulls together current organizational guidance: diversify sport experiences in youth, limit total training load, and emphasize long-term athlete development, not short-term stacking of commitments. PMC

Governing bodies like multi-sport athletes—but emphasize smart periodization and recovery. That’s the central tension with playing two concurrent sports.

Do cross country and soccer “fit” physiologically?

Soccer is a high-intensity intermittent sport: players jog, cruise, accelerate, decelerate, and sprint repeatedly, accumulating thousands of meters with critical bursts of near-max effort. Match analysis and classic work from Bangsbo and colleagues show frequent bouts at or above the lactate threshold layered onto a substantial aerobic base. In-season, coaches often use HIIT to raise the ceiling—but poor load management can spike injury risk. Gatorade Sports Science InstitutePubMed

Cross country loads the aerobic system with steady mileage, threshold work, and select speed sessions. The training goal is economical, durable running at sustained intensities.

Put together, the systems are complementary on paper—aerobic base meets repeated-sprint ability. The catch is dose: because both sports stress the lower body, the total eccentric load (braking, cutting, downhill running), plus the CNS strain of frequent high days, can exceed a teen’s recovery capacity in a single week.

There’s also the “concurrent training” issue: doing endurance and speed-power emphases in the same block can blunt specific adaptations. A large meta-analysis found that adding running-based endurance to strength/power training attenuated strength and hypertrophy more than cycling-based endurance, and lower-body power suffered most when volumes and frequencies were high. Translation: if soccer’s “power” qualities are a top priority, too much continuous running can interfere. PubMedcdof.com.brSemantic Scholar

Bottom line: Cross country and soccer can synergize—but only with careful control of intensity, volume, and sequencing to avoid the interference effect and cumulative tissue stress.

“Everyone has to be on the same page for this to work,” Says Sonia Fisher.

Injury risk: what the data suggest for teen runners (and what it implies for dual-sport athletes)

Studies in high school cross country consistently shows notable injury incidence, with girls typically at higher risk than boys. A landmark study reported ~13–17 injuries per 1,000 athletic exposures, with girls experiencing more time-loss and recurrent injuries. Common sites: lower leg (shin splints), knee, foot (including bone stress injuries). PubMed+1Oxford Academic

Sleep is a powerful (and overlooked) modifier. Adolescents sleeping <8 hours per night had significantly higher injury rates than better-rested peers. Dual-sport schedules compress homework, travel, and social life, which often crowds out sleep. If you green-light a two-sport season, you must plan sleep like a workout. Lippincott JournalsPubMedPMC

Energy availability matters too. And this is achieved by fueling.   Improper fueling, or not eating enough and properly  impairs bone health, endocrine function, and performance and elevates bone stress injury risk. It also impairs sleep, schoolwork and recovery.  

Implication for dual-sport seasons: stacked workloads raise injury risk via (1) higher exposure, (2) less sleep, and (3) greater fueling demands. If any of those three pillars wobble, risk climbs.

Ways to make it work, a positive outcome.

  • Aerobic durability that lasts 80 minutes. XC mileage can lift a soccer player’s ability to maintain high work-rates deep into the second half—if the intensity mix avoids undermining speed-power. Gatorade Sports Science Institute
  • Speed and neuromuscular pop for distance racing. Soccer’s accelerations, cutting, and ball drills provide plyometric-like exposure that can sharpen a runner’s turnover and finishing kick—provided the legs aren’t already cooked by mileage. PubMed
  • Psychological variety. Alternating practice types can reduce monotony, which is a real burnout buffer cited in youth-sport guidance. PMC
  • Holistic athleticism. Multi-sport participation is repeatedly encouraged  for coordination, resilience, and long-term development.  Just not sure in same season 

Risks and trade-offs—where it breaks down

  • Cumulative load & tissue capacity. Back-to-back high days (soccer match → XC intervals) escalate soft-tissue and bone stress without adequate remodeling time, a known recipe for overuse patterns in teen runners. Oxford Academic
  • Adaptation interference. Too much steady endurance can blunt soccer-specific power; too many anaerobic spikes can compromise quality aerobic sessions. Programming matters. PubMed
  • Sleep compression. Evening matches, homework, and weekend races erode sleep—directly tied to higher injury odds. Lippincott Journals
  • Fueling gap & RED-S risk. Two-a-days and stacked events increase energy expenditure; if intake doesn’t keep pace, bone health and performance suffer. British Journal of Sports Medicine
  • Divided commitment. Team cultures and coaches may reasonably expect priority; a divided schedule can create friction and suboptimal attendance.

A practical decision framework for athletes

1) Name a primary sport—and say it out loud.
If college ambition or postseason success hangs on one sport, make it primary. The secondary sport should support, not compete with, the main goal. (This aligns with long-term athlete development guidance to periodize across the year.) PMC

2) Audit the weekly load.

  • Cap total high-intensity exposures at ~2–3 per week across both sports (e.g., one soccer match + one XC quality session + one lighter match or fartlek).
  • Keep easy days truly easy (short aerobic, mobility).
  • Avoid stacking two hard neuromuscular sessions on consecutive days when possible. This reduces interference and overuse risk. PubMed

3) Protect sleep like a starter.
Non-negotiable target: 8–10 hours/night for adolescents; injury risk climbs as sleep drops below ~8. Build the weekly calendar backward from bedtimes, not practice times. Lippincott Journals

4) Fuel for two.

  • Treat dual-sport periods like mini-tournament weeks: carbohydrate availability around training (pre/during/post), sufficient daily protein (~0.3 g/kg per meal across the day), and proactive hydration/sodium.
  • Screen for RED-S risk factors (unintentional weight loss, fatigue, recurrent bone stress injuries, menstrual dysfunction) and loop in an RD or sports med if flags appear. British Journal of Sports Medicine

5) Build a coach-to-coach pact.
Dual sport athletes and their coaches should share calendars and agree on: which days are key, which events take priority, and how to modify when the athlete shows up tired or sore. This is the single biggest cultural determinant of success (or conflict).  This is especially hard if coaches have dual sport athletes from several disciplines.  

“The coaches must understand how each sport affects the other and work together in planning the athlete’s training,” Sonia says. “That only works if there’s communication and respect on both sides.”  

Other Doubles 

Football & soccer crossover is less common and trickier: collision loads (football) layer on top of repeated sprints (soccer), increasing musculoskeletal risk and complicating practice attendance. It’s doable only with very tight guardrails and usually isn’t optimal for in-season development.

Soccer & Volleyball is more of a time management problem.   Soccer a mix of endurance and sprints with mileage load, while volleyball is explosive, jumping, reactionary movements with almost anaerobic load.  These loads may work together if not too intense.    These sports stress different systems (aerobic vs. vertical power), which can be complementary. But the schedule overlap will probably prove to be brutal—both have games multiple nights a week, often at the same time.  There’s little crossover benefit.

Volleyball and Cross Country is a rare mix at the high school level.   They do not compliment each other.  From a physiological standpoint, they probably could be done as a dual sport in the same season.  The stress would come due to recovery from high game volume of volleyball.  

  • Volleyball: short bursts, power, agility.
  • Cross country: sustained endurance, repetitive leg pounding.
  • Fit? Mixed bag. Training doesn’t interfere much physiologically, but volleyball adds a lot of eccentric jumping load on knees/ankles, while XC stresses shins and feet. Recovery time and scheduling logistics make this combo tricky.

Red flags: when to say “not this season”

  • History of bone stress injury, especially tibia, metatarsals, femoral neck. Oxford Academic
  • Persistent sleep debt (<8 hours most nights) despite schedule tweaks. Lippincott Journals
  • Signs of low energy availability/RED-S (unexplained fatigue, declining performance, menstrual dysfunction, recurrent injuries). British Journal of Sports Medicine
  • Uncooperative calendars (three matches + a race week after week) or lack of coach coordination.

“Parents must monitor their athletes, talk to them at the dinner table and ask questions,” Sonia Fisher explains. “Make sure they can handle the stress. You can’t just assume everything is fine. If your child is exhausted, injured, or falling behind in school, it may be too much.”

If you do it—how to make it work

  • Performance priorities. Before the season, mark the 4–6 can’t-miss events (e.g., league matches, invitationals). Everything else flexes around those.
  • “Two-in, one-out” rule. For every two hard or competitive exposures in 72 hours, proactively remove or radically downshift the next session. This respects tissue remodeling and the interference literature. PubMed
  • Recovery playbook. After matches/races: immediate carbs + protein, 10–15 minutes of low-intensity movement, gentle mobility at night, and lights out early. (The sleep-injury connection is so strong it deserves operational status.) Lippincott Journals
  • Strength training stays—but shrinks. Keep 1 short, high-quality full-body session (20–30 minutes) emphasizing robust tendons and hips (RDLs, split squats, calf work, trunk). Avoid to-failure lifting and DOMS during dense weeks to limit interference and fatigue. PubMed
  • Monitor quietly. Simple RPE logs, morning soreness ratings, and a 3-question wellness check (sleep, mood, leg heaviness) catch trouble before it becomes time-loss.
  • Soccer positions matter. You may want to look how positioning compliments another sport.  Midfielders typically accumulate the highest total distance and high-speed efforts; center backs sprint less but perform violent accelerations and aerials; wingers perform frequent max sprints. Pairing midfield workloads with XC racing is the riskiest. If a soccer athlete does XC too, consider adjusting match minutes or training loads by position.

So…is it a good idea?

Maybe—for the right athlete, on the right schedule, with the right adults in the room. But high level success in both,  is a rarity.  The blend of two sports in the same season  can be mutually reinforcing, especially for athletes who thrive on variety and have strong recovery habits. But the default is riskier than most families realize:

  • The concurrent-training literature warns about interference when endurance volume gets high—particularly for lower-body power. PubMed
  • High school cross country data show meaningful injury rates, especially for girls, which will only rise if weekly exposures double. Oxford Academic
  • Sleep and fueling become decisive. Skimp on either, and injuries and plateaus follow. Lippincott JournalsBritish Journal of Sports Medicine

A practical rule of thumb: if you cannot guarantee (1) 8–10 hours of nightly sleep, (2) intentional fueling that matches the true workload, and (3) coach-to-coach coordination that limits total high-intensity exposures to ~2–3 per week, then playing both sports in the same season is likely to undercut performance and increase risk.

For some, the smarter path is one primary in-season sport plus out-of-season cross-training with the other—capturing the long-term benefits of multi-sport development without the in-season pileup. That’s exactly the balance youth-sport experts are advocating. PMCNFHS

As a high school and college coach, for the last three decades,  I have counseled many athletes in making the decision on whether to do one or two sports.  My prevailing opinion is to do one sport 100% rather than two at a lesser percentage and enjoy the success.  I know that is what these athletes do not want to hear.   But for every Grant Fisher, who eventually became a one sport fall athlete, his senior year, there are hundreds of athletes that fall short because being a two sport/one season athlete is a big load to carry. 

Key sources

Joe Carei

, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Leave a comment